Improve scenario planning with an optimized EPM solution
On Sept. 18, the Federal Reserve cut interest rates for the first time in four years, sparking renewed confidence and a wave of opportunities across the economy. This long-awaited announcement, however, brings new challenges for the banking industry, particularly with the surge in M&A activity.
As banks reconsider their strategic outlook in these new market conditions, they must have a flexible approach to foster growth and combat stagnation.
Previously, banks may have relied on spreadsheet-based tools for forecasting and performance management but increasingly, these tools are insufficient. It’s crucial for banks to implement an effective enterprise performance management (EPM) system to provide more sophisticated budgeting, forecasting and reporting functionalities to assess overall business health.
“EPM systems extend beyond supporting just an institution’s finance team. They’re integral to the entire enterprise strategy,” said Mike Pilch, Grant Thornton Technology Modernization Managing Director. “As organizations develop new strategies and assess whether their team members possess the necessary skill sets, EPM systems can play a pivotal role in aligning and executing these strategies effectively.”
That’s because EPM systems create efficiencies by establishing repeatable, systematic processes that deliver reliable results in a timely manner. By placing the burden of the process on technology, organizations can more effectively utilize talent and redeploy their resources for value-added analysis and other tasks.
An optimally functioning EPM system unleashes data from a bank’s systems as well as external sources to provide:
- Accurate reporting
- Unparalleled visibility into operations
- Analysis of trends and opportunities
- Ultimately, input that can provide better strategic direction
Banks or credit unions that are operating with spreadsheet processes will see noticeable improvements upon embracing EPM. The powerful EPM tools that once were only affordable for banking giants are now easily within the budgetary reach of much smaller retail banks and credit unions. The affordability has leveled the playing field, allowing all financial institutions to move away from running their businesses via spreadsheets.
Meanwhile, banks that already have an EPM system may find benefits from upgrading. Some banks undergo EPM improvements when they move from on-premise systems to cloud-based solutions, and others may want to upgrade to a tool specifically geared toward their industry, guided by an implementer with the relevant banking knowledge and experience.
“Tailoring an EPM system to address an organization’s specific use cases is always beneficial,” said Zac Taylor, Grant Thornton Technology Modernization Principal. “A system that analyzes data without considering the specific context of a specific organization’s operations may provide flawed insights or forecasts.”
Furthermore, Pilch noted that an effective EPM system can consolidate information from across the business to inform management of potential issues at a strategic level, presenting a comprehensive narrative that identifies opportunities to create value for the bank as a whole.
“There’s no better time than now to implement an EPM solution,” Pilch said. “These systems enable organizations to prepare for strategic decisions by efficiently modeling scenarios involving factors such as interest rates, credit quality, prepayment speeds and significant economic events, helping to resolve complexities and mitigate potential risks in both the short and long term.”
Here’s what banks need to do to take full advantage of the benefits an optimized EPM system can bring in this time of change.
More EPM insights
Assess your needs
Banking leaders who are looking to implement or update an EPM system need to first verify that it will support the key aspects of their budgeting and planning processes. These typically include:
- Functionality to support budgeting, forecasting, management reporting and offering insights analysis to better understand drivers and impacts to earnings.
- Balance sheet-focused planning processes.
- Planning that encompasses different rate-related product types — loans, deposits, investments and borrowings.
- Projections for rates of the different rate-related products.
- Rate-related revenues and expenses, which are derived from the projected average balances and rates.
Interest rate risk presents the biggest challenge to these systems because the models need to account for different interest rate scenarios and how rates will change over time. The models need to be flexible enough to adjust for different rate scenarios.
Banks also need to make sure their EPM systems accurately forecast their expected credit losses across different product lines so they can calculate their reserves in a compliant manner. The expected credit losses will be different based on changes in rate scenarios and other factors as well, and the EPM forecasts need to take this into account.
Retail bank EPM data sourcing needs
Bank EPM systems need data from:
- The general ledger
- Loan and CD processing systems, describing instrument detail (including rates) and transactions
- Treasury systems such as ALM models
- Call center/branch transactions
- HR systems
- Funds transfer pricing (if calculated externally)
All banking EPM systems also need the ability to:
- Flexibly integrate information from multiple sources, including financial accounting and non-financial drivers and metrics.
- Calculate average balances for all planned balance sheet accounts.
- Plan for the different rate-related product types (loans, deposits, investments and borrowings). For example, the system will need the ability to calculate fixed- and variable-rate loans with options for 30/360, actual/360, and actual/365 interest accrual calculations.
- Model net interest margin (NIM) for different interest rate scenarios. The system will need to be able to assign products to a rate index (the sum of the rate index plus spread equals the product interest rate). And the system will need to plan interest for existing product balances as well as projected new additions.
- Load existing rate-related account portfolio balances and the projected runoff by month.
- Plan new rate-related portfolio additions at projected rates.
- Calculate FTP using either an instrument-based approach or a pool-based methodology.
- Model the profitability of different channels and products across the enterprise. For example, modeling the profitability of each branch is a must.
- Enable self-service reporting.
The ultimate goal of this budgeting effort should be real-time planning, enabled by artificial intelligence that synthesizes immense quantities of data to enable better forecasting and quick pivots. In the past, forecasts have been performed almost entirely based on historical data.
Tracking separate layers
Bank EPM systems should provide the ability to get insights and provide forecasts separately for different branches, products and channels as well as the bank’s overall organic growth and its strategic planning initiatives.
Initiatives should be forecasted and tracked in separate layers or buckets, which are incorporated into the base organic plan to get the total plan.
Key analytics for optimal bank operations
- Headcount/FTE
- Employee analytics such as branch transaction volumes and staffing by hour
- Cross-selling metrics
- New loans and deposits by channel
- Net interest margin (NIM)
- Efficiency ratio (non-interest expense/revenue)
- Loans/deposits (total loans over total deposits to measure liquidity)
- Return on assets
- Households
Profitability modeling and tracking will help banking leaders better understand issues that will be undiscoverable in simple spreadsheet allocation processes. Effective EPM modeling will help bank leaders understand:
- Which products, channels, services and customers are the most and least profitable — and why.
- Volumes and locations of transactions, cannibalization and household relationships.
“Deposits tend to make customer relationships stickier if additional products, such as loans, can be offered along with them,” Tripp said. “The ability to analyze product-type revenue by onboarded channel provides informed decision-making, such as digital banking and branch strategy.”
The benefits of scenario modeling
EPM systems also should provide banks with scenario modeling information that will be useful.
EPM tools enable organizations to model various scenarios in response to market changes, interpret a range of potential outcomes and provide data-driven insights that help leaders proactively monitor changes and make critical decisions to protect the business.
With the increase in M&A activity across all industries, including banking, EPM systems are more relevant in M&A modeling than ever.
In the acquisition of another bank, analysts are able to interpret the potential impact the acquired bank will have on the collective bank, including evaluating the impact on corporate operations, interest rate risk and cost synergies. Once acquired, organizations can systematically integrate the entity with their EPM system to immediately interpret the impact of the acquisition, identify potential synergies and evaluate a range of potential outcomes by incorporating the acquisition.
Other types of scenario modeling include:
- Sensitivity analysis. Potential changes in business growth and financing strategies can be tested for the impact they would have on the business. Expected changes in loan/deposit growth, yields/rates, funding strategies, bank ratios and other market changes may be modeled.
- P&L impacts of key promotions such as sign-up bonuses or highly favorable rate offerings.
- Impacts of new branches or channels — or branch consolidation.
- Changes in product or service offerings.
“You want to have the ability to create pro forma financial statements of the potential results of different combinations of branch expansions, closures and changes — and other initiatives and strategies,” said Grant Thornton Business Applications Principal Brian Eccher. “You can layer in the impact of various different actions into your planning or forecasting.”
An effective EPM system will also be able to measure impacts from different projected interest rate scenarios, or yield curves. Banking asset/liability models (ALM) will measure the spread over time. Incorporating this ALM information into the annual budget enables greater reliability in rate-related revenue and expense projections. This improved reliability can also be used to understand variable revenues, such as fees, as well as expenses, such as labor costs.
Getting started
Advanced forecasting capabilities based on increasingly powerful technologies are driving the potential for banks to make substantial improvements in their achievement of profitable growth, especially during market fluctuations.
In this environment, banks that continue to rely on spreadsheets for their forecasting will be at a disadvantage. And banks with EPM systems that aren’t specifically designed for their industry may not be able to measure some of the key metrics that they need to evaluate their progress and potential.
Whether banks incorporate these systems themselves or turn to third parties for assistance, the value of data-based decision-making in the current market environment tends to far outweigh the costs of implementation.
Contacts:
Zac Taylor
Principal, Technology Modernization Services
Grant Thornton Advisors LLC
Zac Taylor is a Principal within Grant Thornton’s Organizational and Operational Transformation practice.
Dallas, Texas
Industries
- Asset management
- Banking
- Life sciences
- Technology, media & telecommunications
- Manufacturing, Transportation & Distribution
- Construction & real estate
Service Experience
- Advisory
- Operations and performance
Content disclaimer
This Grant Thornton Advisors LLC content provides information and comments on current issues and developments. It is not a comprehensive analysis of the subject matter covered. It is not, and should not be construed as, accounting, legal, tax, or professional advice provided by Grant Thornton Advisors LLC. All relevant facts and circumstances, including the pertinent authoritative literature, need to be considered to arrive at conclusions that comply with matters addressed in this content.
Grant Thornton Advisors LLC and its subsidiary entities are not licensed CPA firms.
For additional information on topics covered in this content, contact a Grant Thornton Advisors LLC professional.
Enterprise performance management in other industries
Our fresh thinking
No Results Found. Please search again using different keywords and/or filters.
Share with your network
Share